Professor A, who is based in Europe, has been funded to develop ICT solutions relevant for rural health in a central Asian republic. She is keen to contribute to building local capacity in research and interaction design skills, and so is collaborating on the research with the IT department of a university in the capital. To support the collaborative investigation of local problems and participatory design of solutions, Professor A has appointed Dr C, a member of staff from the University, who is conducting the primary field work. Reading Dr C’s reports from the field, Professor A is concerned that Dr C’s participatory sessions may not be including and enabling sufficient input from women in the villages. Discussing the issues, Dr C says that he is working very hard to include the voices of women. However, from informal conversations Professor A knows that Dr C’s religious & social background suggests it is natural and appropriate for men & women to have very different roles, with women’s role being less autonomous.
- What should Professor A do?
- What might she have done differently to avoid this situation?
- What are the ethics, roles & relationships relevant to this situation?
- What other questions do we need to ask about this scenario?
When leaving a comment, please specify the question(s) you are answering. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteMy first thoughts are that research cannot deliver up realistic results unless it is fully inclusive.
ReplyDelete* What should Prof A do?
Bearing in mind the above she should start again
* What might she have done differently to avoid this situation?
As Prof A is aware be it through informal means of the cultural, religious and social difference between men and women, she ought to have taken this into account when designing the research methods.
A female researcher who could have accessed the spaces women use, for prayer, relaxation and or work would have been ideal
*What does other questions do we need to ask about this scenario
Is Prof A helping to reinforce views that treat women less favourably than men by employing a male reseacher she knows to hold such views?